Get Around Caboolture is a proud member of TPA (AITPM)  | Better Streets Coalition | Bicycle Network |  Strong Towns |  Parking Reform Network

University students seated in a tiered lecture theatre at the Polytechnic University of Tirana in Albania, during a guest lecture by Dorina Pojani.

S3E20 PnP The True Cost of Cars Dorina Pojani

S3E20 PnP The True Cost of Cars Dorina Pojani

The True Cost of Cars with Dorina Pojani

The cost of cars extends far beyond what drivers pay for their vehicles, fuel, registration and parking. Roads, congestion, pollution, land and road crashes all carry costs, and many of these are shared across society.

In this episode of Streets and People, University of Queensland planning researcher Dorina Pojani returns to discuss 2 studies that raise important questions about how Australia spends its transport budgets.

One examines the economic cost of our car-dependent transport system. The other investigates whether high-quality cycling infrastructure makes a measurable difference in suburban communities.

Together, they offer some surprising findings about public spending, transport choice and the opportunities available to governments, planners and communities.

3 key insights

1. Drivers pay approximately half the total cost of automobility. Dorina’s research found that governments cover the other half, with total costs running into billions of dollars.

2. Protected cycling infrastructure generates additional journeys. Researchers found that high-quality cycling facilities in suburban development areas encouraged new cycling trips, rather than simply attracting people who were already cycling elsewhere.

3. Transport dependence creates unequal burdens. People who cannot afford a car, cannot drive or live somewhere without practical alternatives can face significant difficulties. Dorina argues that these are systemic issues requiring government action.

1 surprising moment

Dorina expected drivers to pay perhaps 75% or 80% of the cost of automobility, with governments subsidising the remainder.

The actual finding was much closer to a 50–50 split.

Even as a transport planning researcher who had been teaching students about these costs for years, Dorina was surprised by the scale of government expenditure.

1 real-world example

One of the most encouraging findings came from newly developed suburban areas in South East Qld.

Researchers compared locations with high-quality cycling infrastructure against locations with poorer facilities. They found that the better infrastructure encouraged additional cycling trips, including journeys people would otherwise never have made.

Children were among the prominent users. Dorina described the positive example of a parent cycling alongside a child to school, demonstrating how good infrastructure can create more possibilities for everyday suburban travel.

Table of contents

  1. Understanding the cost of cars
  2. What the research reveals about public spending
  3. The hidden costs of parking
  4. Why road crashes appear in economic calculations
  5. How protected cycling infrastructure changes behaviour
  6. Children and cycling in suburban communities
  7. Enjoyment, convenience and transport choice
  8. Who bears the burden of car dependence?
  9. What governments and planners can do
  10. Where transport research could go next
  11. Making research useful beyond universities

Understanding the cost of cars

Dorina’s interest in the economics of car dependence developed through her work teaching transport planning at the University of Queensland.

She found that many students understood the costs of owning and operating their own cars. They knew about registration, parking fees and the price of the vehicle itself.

What they often had not considered was the wider system supporting private car use.

Dorina describes this as automobility. It encompasses the infrastructure and activities that make car travel possible, along with their wider economic effects.

A road must be built and maintained. Cars need places to park at home and at their destinations. Congestion creates delays for other travellers. Pollution has costs, and land devoted to roads and parking could have other uses.

For example, Dorina points out that land used for roads could also be used for trees.

Each component contributes to the overall economic cost.

Her research was inspired by a study conducted by researchers at Harvard University examining automobility costs in Massachusetts. Dorina and her colleagues adapted that accounting approach to examine Australia’s 5 largest states.

The aim was to identify the different components of the system and assign monetary values to them.

The resulting figures were considerably larger than Dorina had anticipated.

What the research reveals about public spending

One of the most significant findings concerns who pays.

Dorina explains that individual drivers cover approximately half the total cost of automobility, while governments contribute the other half.

The costs run into billions of dollars.

This surprised Dorina because she had previously assumed drivers might cover around 75% or 80% of the total.

Students had sometimes challenged her teaching by pointing out that drivers already pay substantial amounts through registration, vehicle ownership and parking charges.

She understood that government subsidies were involved, but she wanted a more precise figure.

The research provided one.

The findings also raise questions about how public money is allocated, particularly when governments are responsible for maintaining extensive road networks.

During our conversation, we discussed whether increasing the availability of protected cycling infrastructure might eventually help reduce the costs associated with roads.

Dorina explained that roads remain essential for many purposes, including buses, freight, bicycles and other vehicles.

However, she identified the inefficient use of road space by single-occupant cars as an important consideration.

A car occupies considerably more space than the person travelling inside it. When several people share a vehicle, the available space is used more efficiently.

Buses provide another example. Dorina points out that even a small shuttle bus can use road space more efficiently than several cars carrying only their drivers.

The hidden costs of parking

Parking emerged as another substantial component of the cost of cars.

During our conversation, I initially referred to a figure of approximately $3 billion for non-residential parking construction. Looking again at the figures, I realised I had been referring to a single state’s costs.

The broader amounts were considerably higher.

Dorina explained that the study accounted for several separate components: residential parking construction, residential parking land value, non-residential parking construction and non-residential parking land value.

The distinction matters because the expense of constructing a parking space is separate from the value of the land it occupies.

When those costs are combined, the totals reach billions of dollars.

We discussed the different ways land and public resources might be used, including housing, businesses, education and healthcare.

Dorina raised higher education as an example, reflecting on funding pressures in her own sector and wondering whether reducing parking expenditure could allow more money to be directed towards universities.

These questions illustrate why understanding the complete cost of cars matters for public policy.

Spending on one part of the transport system affects the resources available for other priorities.

Why road crashes appear in economic calculations

Content note: This section discusses road deaths, injuries and the economic valuation of human life.

Road crashes are another substantial cost identified in Dorina’s research.

She reports an annual economic cost of $13.5 billion in Australia associated with road crashes.

To calculate these costs, researchers considered the severity of injuries and the number of deaths, using an established economic valuation approach.

Dorina explained that the study used the value of a statistical life calculated by the Office of Best Practice Regulation. The figure used was $5.1 million in 2021.

This was one of the more difficult parts of our conversation.

Putting a monetary value on human life can feel deeply uncomfortable, particularly for people who have experienced the death or serious injury of someone they love.

Dorina acknowledged that no amount of money could compensate for the pain, grief and loss associated with such an experience.

The economic methodology nevertheless allows researchers and governments to account for road trauma when assessing the wider costs of transport.

It also makes road safety one of the areas governments can examine when considering how to reduce the economic burden of automobility.

How protected cycling infrastructure changes behaviour

Dorina’s second study provides a more encouraging perspective on what happens when governments invest in different transport options.

Working through a research arrangement involving the University of Queensland and the Department of Transport and Main Roads, her team examined high-quality cycling infrastructure in priority development areas in South East Qld.

These were suburban locations, including areas beyond Brisbane.

Researchers compared sites with good cycling facilities against sites where infrastructure was less developed.

They used a statistical approach known as differences in differences to examine the effect of infrastructure quality.

The findings were encouraging.

High-quality cycling infrastructure attracted users and generated new trips.

This was particularly significant because the increase represented journeys that people otherwise would not have made, rather than simply diverting existing cyclists from another route.

For Dorina, the suburban context made the findings especially interesting.

She had encountered the assumption that people would have little reason to cycle in suburban locations.

The research demonstrated that people did use the facilities when suitable infrastructure was provided.

Dorina suggested that even greater cycling activity might be possible in denser urban areas, where she believes there is substantial potential demand.

Children and cycling in suburban communities

Children were among the prominent users of the cycling facilities examined in the study.

Dorina increasingly describes these routes as micromobility infrastructure because they can accommodate bicycles, e-scooters and other small vehicles.

The research also included interviews with adults about their experiences and attitudes.

Parents expressed concerns about allowing children to travel independently, particularly at intersections.

Even where the infrastructure was considered very good, parents wanted a high level of safety before allowing their children to cycle alone.

Dorina recognised these concerns.

Nevertheless, the study observed children using the infrastructure, sometimes accompanied by their parents.

She described the example of a mother cycling alongside her child to school instead of making the journey by car.

For suburban communities, this represents a practical opportunity to make everyday travel more varied.

The researchers did not interview children directly because of the university’s ethical requirements for research involving minors.

Consequently, the study could not establish directly how children felt about their journeys.

Enjoyment, convenience and transport choice

One particularly interesting part of our conversation concerned why people choose to cycle.

Dorina explained that enjoyment and convenience are major motivations.

Environmental concerns and financial savings may also matter, but she identified enjoyment and convenience as the leading reasons people take up cycling.

This has implications for how transport infrastructure is understood.

The quality of a journey matters to the person making it.

We also discussed whether high-quality cycling facilities influence people’s decisions about where to live.

Dorina said that the infrastructure was regarded as an attractive neighbourhood amenity.

Although the study did not examine property prices, researchers asked residents whether the cycling facilities had influenced their decision to move into the area.

Many said they had.

Dorina suggested this could provide developers with an incentive to work alongside governments and councils to provide good micromobility infrastructure.

The findings indicate that transport choice can be an appealing feature of suburban development.

Who bears the burden of car dependence?

The economic cost of cars also raises questions about fairness.

Dorina discussed people living in remote or highly car-dependent locations, where practical alternatives may be unavailable.

For someone who must travel long distances to reach shops, schools, healthcare or other daily needs, giving up a car may be unrealistic.

Dorina was clear that the research is directed towards governments and the wider transport system.

She also highlighted the gendered dimensions of travel.

Women frequently carry substantial responsibilities for caring for children, managing households and supporting other family members.

Their journeys can involve several destinations, including workplaces, shops, childcare and visits to relatives.

These complex travel patterns can be difficult to manage using existing public transport services.

Dorina also discussed her own decision to live without a car.

She questioned why people who do not own cars should contribute through taxation to costs associated with private car use.

We extended that discussion to people who cannot drive or cannot afford a vehicle.

For them, living without a car may be a matter of circumstance rather than preference.

Dorina recognised this as another important issue of transport justice.

Her central concern is that governments need to address the structural conditions creating dependence and unequal access.

What governments and planners can do

Towards the end of our conversation, I asked what someone working in a council or transport planning department could do with these findings.

Dorina suggested examining the different cost categories identified in the automobility study.

Planners could use the published figures to identify areas where costs might be reduced relatively quickly and with limited disruption.

She mentioned several possibilities.

One was reducing expenditure on non-residential parking construction.

Another was examining road safety measures that could lower crash-related costs.

Accelerating the uptake of electric vehicles was another option she raised for reducing pollution costs.

Dorina emphasised that governments would need to evaluate which measures were practical, affordable and suitable for implementation.

The process would also need to account for people who remain heavily dependent on cars.

The research provides an accounting framework that planners and decision-makers can use when considering these questions.

Where transport research could go next

Dorina believes the next important research task is to examine the costs of alternatives to private car ownership.

She suggested investigating scenarios involving car sharing, carpooling and ride-hailing services.

If these alternatives prove expensive for individuals, governments could examine whether supporting them financially might be worthwhile.

Further research could consider the costs and benefits of providing more public transport.

Dorina distinguished between different forms of investment.

Buses can be comparatively inexpensive to introduce because they operate on roads. Rail projects, particularly those involving tunnels, require much larger investments.

She also acknowledged that major infrastructure projects can experience cost overruns.

Any proposed alternative therefore needs careful economic evaluation.

The broader research question is how much it would cost to move towards a transport system offering more options, and what benefits those investments might produce over time.

Making research useful beyond universities

Dorina ended our conversation by explaining why she values sharing her research with a wider audience.

She wants planners, politicians and other decision-makers to use academic findings when considering how to improve communities.

The cost of cars study gives governments a clearer picture of where public resources are being spent.

The cycling infrastructure study provides evidence that investment in high-quality facilities can encourage additional journeys, including in suburban areas where cycling demand may previously have been underestimated.

Together, the studies provide useful information for considering future transport investments.

They also show why the details matter. Different transport options have different costs, and those costs are experienced by individuals, governments and communities in different ways.

Dorina’s research invites us to examine those choices carefully and consider how public resources might support greater accessibility and more practical transport options.

The encouraging finding is that changing infrastructure can change travel behaviour. The next task is to understand how governments can use that evidence to provide more choice while managing costs responsibly.

That is where Dorina hopes her research will make a difference.

To read the reports we discuss, go here:

  1. Pre-print economics article (free to download):
    https://www.researchgate.net/publication/406903123_Revealing_the_true_costs_of_automobility_in_Australia
  2. TMR research on micromobility lanes:
    https://espace.library.uq.edu.au/view/UQ:3f084e4

Podcast theme music: Doctor Yes | Yari | Bensound

GetAroundCaboolture.au

The Streets and People Podcast

Every day in Caboolture and Morayfield, people get left behind because they can’t drive. Some are too young. Some are older. Others live with disability or manage on a low income. You probably know 1 or 2 people in that situation.

We keep asking the same question: Why do cars get the red carpet while everyone else gets the gravel?

Get Around Caboolture is a local movement focused on practical transport solutions that work for more people. Through real stories and expert insights, our podcast highlights what’s missing – and what’s possible.

Our podcast series:

People & Projects (PnP): Interviews with researchers, advocates, and professionals working on transport solutions across Australia.

Not Everyone Drives (NED): Conversations with locals who don’t drive, sharing how transport access, or the lack of it, shapes their everyday lives.

Road Rules 360 (RR360)
Co-hosted with John Burrill, this series looks at road rules from all angles, with a focus on people walking, riding, scooting, or using mobility aids.

You’re invited to explore the episodes and learn more at www.GetAroundCaboolture.au.

Get Around Caboolture is a community movement advocating for more transport choice and less hassle.

Here are easy ways you can help us get better transport 

Feel free to share the love and post an episode to a friend or colleague you think would enjoy listening to it. 

If you like what we’re doing on our podcast, please review and rate as this helps the analytics :-)

Click here to find out how to help us get more transport options! 

Laura's family crossing the road
If you're interested in what we do, we could do with your support

Get Around Caboolture is a community movement advocating for more travel options for people in
Caboolture & Morayfield. 

Our Goals

1. All children can ride to school on safe streets 

2. All young adults can get to work or study without needing a car so they begin adulthood without a debt of $15,000 a year. 

A lack of transport options leads to a high financial burden for
families, businesses and governments.

The only way we can be sustainable for the long term is with your help. 

Photo: Dan Peled/The Guardian